The
Wrong Protest
Try marching against a failed education establishment...
[Xiaochin
Claire Yan] 3/30/06
For
the third straight day this week, tens of thousands of
students walked out of their schools Wednesday to protest
against legislation that would make illegal immigration
a felony.
The Los Angeles County Office of Education reported that
more than 36,000 students walked out from district schools
on Tuesday. Among heavily Hispanic schools in downtown
Los Angeles the news of the boycott spread through hallway
posters and public address systems. Many schools went
into lockdown, with some officials literally fighting
with protestors to keep the doors of the school closed
and the students in the classrooms.
While
some students appeared to truly care about the issue
at hand, others admitted that they simply did not want
to be at school. Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa
met with student protestors and won cheers for his opposition
to the legislation. Yet later in the day, when he came
out of city hall to tell students it was time to return
to school, he drew boos, taunts and obscenities in Spanish.
Guest
Contributor
Xiaochin Claire Yan
Xiaochin
Claire Yan is a Policy Fellow in Education Studies
at the Pacific Research Institute in San Francisco.[Yan index] |
Many of those
interviewed at the protests echoed the message that they and
their families
were just here to make a better
life. Sadly, by walking out of the classroom — a move that
was not only disruptive, but also financially costly to schools
whose federal funding is dependent on student attendance — they
took themselves away from the one place that offers them the
best chance at a better life. Yet some school officials appeared
unconcerned with the loss of valuable learning time and said
they were please to see this week’s show of “political
activism” from students.
While the students were out protesting, the California Department
of Education released new numbers showing that nearly a third
of English learner students in the class of 2006 have not yet
passed the high school exit exam. Among Hispanic students at
large 18 percent have yet to pass. Meanwhile, the dropout rate
in Los Angeles is estimated to be near 30 percent and higher
among Hispanic students.
Partly to blame is that for years basic skills such as reading,
writing, and math have been obscured by multiculturalism, self-esteem,
and other politically correct fads. Rather than teaching immigrant
students how to assimilate into the civic mainstream of America
and giving them the tools they need to make that better life,
schools have instead let them pass from grade to grade without
really keeping track of their progress or holding anyone accountable.
Students and parents themselves must also take responsibility.
Where is the outcry over letting generation after generation
of immigrant students pass through our schools with no marketable
real world skills? Where are the mass protests over the now discredited
bilingual education blunder that kept immigrants, mostly those
from Mexico, from achieving English literacy?
Public demonstrations are an exercise in freedom of expression.
But as with the Proposition 187 protests in 1994, many students
are being exploited by those who urge them to stay out of school
in solidarity with the Latino community. All immigrant communities
need better educated youths.
In these protests, much has been made of the fact that America
is a nation of immigrants. Indeed. But if this immigrant success
is to continue, we need to help those who are here, and those
who will continue to arrive, understand the tradition and heritage
of this country and gain the skills needed to build a bright
future. CRO
copyright 2006 Pacific Reasearch Institute
§
|